
1762
Beatty's Mill
George Beatty bought fifty acres on this bend of the Musconetcong around 1762 and built the first grist mill in the area.
The mill worked. A village grew up around it and took his name.

Beattystown Mill
A whole early-1800s stone mill, yours alone — lofts, a library, a bar over the water. 60 miles from NYC.
Book direct · no platform service fee

An architect left the original millrace flowing beneath the living room, with an arched stone window and a pane of glass over the water.
4.91
Guest favorite · 86 reviews
“The place was amazing!!! The host was very accommodating. Wish we could have stayed longer. We hope to go back again. The place was superb!”
“Wow!! The pictures don't do this place justice. Amazing stay for our family!! We could have lingered for days looking at fascinating artifacts and architectural features of this historical gem. Gorgeous grounds, landscaping, and of course river views even from the master bath shower. Tons of space for everyone to spread out and also gather as a family of 7. Very responsive host. A TRULY unique experience!!”

1762
George Beatty bought fifty acres on this bend of the Musconetcong around 1762 and built the first grist mill in the area.
The mill worked. A village grew up around it and took his name.

c. 1810
Beatty's original mill burned. What replaced it, around 1810 to 1820, is the building you sleep in: four stories of stone, arched windows in the oldest sections, a turbine pit at the east end.
It ran as the S. B. Fisher Grist Mill for most of the nineteenth century.

1980s
After eighty quiet years, the mill met Charles Buckley — a Yale-trained architect who redesigned and reconstructed it as a home.
His signature move is the one you feel first: he left the original millrace flowing beneath the living room, and put a glass floor panel over it.
The Musconetcong has turned wheels on this bend since 1762 — and it still runs beneath the living room

1990
In 1990 the whole village was listed on the National Register of Historic Places as the Beattystown Historic District, with the mill as a contributing structure — the building the district is named for.
“The most important trade center on the southwestern edge of what would become Warren County.”
The whole mill is yours: the lofts, the library, the bar over the water, and the river Beatty built his wheel on. Cast a line from your own bank, pour a drink above the millrace, and add a small chapter of your own.
4.91
Guest favorite · 86 reviews
“The place was amazing!!! The host was very accommodating. Wish we could have stayed longer. We hope to go back again. The place was superb!”
“Wow!! The pictures don't do this place justice. Amazing stay for our family!! We could have lingered for days looking at fascinating artifacts and architectural features of this historical gem. Gorgeous grounds, landscaping, and of course river views even from the master bath shower. Tons of space for everyone to spread out and also gather as a family of 7. Very responsive host. A TRULY unique experience!!”
“What a beautiful, unique place to stay! We wanted to explore this fascinating home right away before we even brought our bags inside. There are fun surprises so be sure to read the printed house manual. The kitchen was well stocked (we could have used a larger baking sheet) and the dining table comfortably seated our group of 10. […] The staircases are stunning, though anyone who is afraid of heights may not be comfortable navigating them. Bedrooms were comfortable; 3 of the 5 rooms had split a/c units. Bathrooms were well-appointed & the master bath is huge! Being on the river is so beautiful. We loved paddling the kayaks upstream and floating back. There is highway noise but the birds in the trees make it very peaceful. Sitting by the fire outside in the evening was lovely. The first morning, we were thrilled to see two black bear cubs emerge from the bushes across the river! We had an amazing experience”
“We had an absolutely wonderful stay! Diego was an incredibly responsive and attentive host, and the property was beautiful, well kept, and thoughtfully maintained. There were so many things to see and do there, which made our trip even more enjoyable. We created so many special memories here and would gladly stay again. Highly recommended!”
Book direct with us — no platform fees, and you deal with the people who keep the mill, not a support queue.
Whole mill · sleeps 12
4.91 · no platform fee